CASE: H-1B Visa Petition
PETITIONER: Culture Center in Ohio
BENEFICIARY: Chinese Assistant Program Development Director
Our client is a Culture Center in Ohio that offers after-school and weekend educational programs for children and young students in the Greater Cleveland area. They contacted our office in the middle of March 2013 to seek legal assistance for its foreign beneficiary’s H-1B visa petition.
The beneficiary is a Chinese who obtained her Bachelor’s in Economics in China and also an MBA degree in the United States. The proffered position for the Beneficiary was for an Assistant Program Development Director which we argued qualified as a specialty occupation. We argued that the minimum requirement for this position is a Bachelor’s Degree in Economics/Business or its equivalent.
Upon retention, our firm prepared and eventually filed the H-1B visa petition with various supporting documents on April 1, 2013 via regular processing. The USCIS California Service Center issued a Request for Evidence (RFE) on July 2, 2013.
The USCIS argued that the offered position does not qualify as a “specialty occupation.” They claimed that the business was new and that a Bachelor’s degree was not required for this position. They claimed that the beneficiary’s position is not specialized and complex enough to be qualified as a specialty occupation as the law requires.
In response to the RFE, our office argued in an 6-page response brief with 14 exhibits that the nature of the specific duties are so specialized and complex that knowledge required to perform the duties is usually associated with the attainment of a Bachelor’s degree. Moreover, we argued that the degree requirement is common to the industry in parallel positions among similar organizations.
Our office filed the response to the USCIS California Service Center on August 10, 2013. Our client’s H-1B application was approved on October 16, 2013. Now the Beneficiary can work for the Petitioner on an H-1B status until September 20, 2016